| Author | Comment | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
Gerbubble Bug |
INFORMAL SURVEY - GLASS VS BAMBOO VS GRAPHITE |
Lead | ||
|
Just curious about how each person feels about Fiberglass vs Graphite vs Bamboo. If your invited to go on a trip for Warmwater Fishing in a fairly open lake,
with some wind, and populations of Bass, Sunfish, Crappie, Perch, etc & can bring only one rod, what is your "go to rod". I'll start off.
Sage XP 9 1/2 FT - 6 WT with a WF-7-F Cortland 444 SL Bass Taper. Your thoughts?
|
||||
|
|
||||
Flytackle |
#1 | |||
|
Fenwick Fenglass 755 with Wulff TT5. Bass or bream, it rules the roost. Alec
|
||||
|
|
||||
Cornmuse |
#2 | |||
|
Truthfully, I probably take my Orvis TLS 906-4 midflex with a BB taper 6wt line. It's my fav "all-rounder". But it would be very, very hard for
me to not bring glass too. It will be an 8' 6wt and will be a Browning, TL Johnson or possibly the McFarland if there isn't a lot of heavy cover. The
McFarland bends nice with a fish on...
"Live each season as it passes; breathe the air, drink the
drink, taste the fruit,
- Henry David Thoreau
|
||||
|
|
||||
bill0215 |
#3 | |||
|
Fenwick floater bum, a 7 wt , 6'10" glass rod that can throw big flies and still allow for fun with BGs.
Last Edited By: bill0215 10/11/07 17:00:33.
Edited 1 time.
|
||||
|
|
||||
gillbuster |
#4 | |||
|
Have got a lot of miles on my Presidential Wonderod FY510 7 1/2 in length. As you can see it handles all sorts of hefty BG, SMB, Crappie and perch...
|
||||
|
|
||||
pearow |
#5 | |||
|
First, I would complain to the high heavens about only getting to bring one rod; but then I would probably reach for my 5 weight Scott; simply because of its
versatility. If I were fishing a little creek or small river for gills and bass, I would have my ff705 fenwick in hand; if i was fishing a lake for bream on
the beds, I would have my Orvis super-fine 3 weight; if I was fishing popping bugs on a warm water river i would opt for my fenwick 807 or my Heddon 7 weight;
and on and on; I couldn't choose just one-p-
|
||||
|
|
||||
bamboo1963 |
#6 | |||
|
I'd bring an 8 1/2', 9wt. Orvis bamboo rod lined with an 8wt. Rio Clouser line.
When fishing from my boat, I bring 2 rods, the one listed above, and a 9', 7wt. Winston IM6 rod lined with a 7wt. Rio full sinking line.
Your Signature ...
|
||||
|
|
||||
JeffSod |
#7 | |||
|
Last Season it would have been my glass Fenwick FF80 7wt this season it has been my glass Curt Gowdy 8' 7wt. My 5wt Leon Chandler glass is an exceptional
caster too but I don't use that as a daily driver only special days.
|
||||
|
|
||||
spinzo |
#8 | |||
|
I'm with Alec. Love my Fenglass. Tosses a big enough bug to be a good bass rod (and I've handled my two biggest LMB on that stick with tremendous
joy), but supple enough to be sporting with decent panfish on the line.
Mike |
||||
|
|
||||
TXTrout |
#9 | |||
|
Bamboo.
I would bring a 3 pc version of a P.H. Young Para 15 (8ft) that I made a few years ago that I can fish a 7wt Rio Clouser or a full sinking line. It will even handle an 8wt line when asked too. This rod is a small powerhouse. However, if you throw river strippers into the mix, it really doesn't have the butt. However, there is always an 8'6" Gary Howell's based 6wt. It will also handle a 7wt when needed. just not as strong, a slower rod. .
Robert.
"Some paths are best not taken alone" John W. Barfield |
||||
|
|
||||
flyfishing4goldentrout |
#10 | |||
|
Interesting Question. I fish Lake Isabella during the summer months when the river is full of commerical rafters and the banks lined with camping turist. Our
lake at least this last summer when full has a varity of species. Trout, Bass, Catfish, Crappie and bluegill to name the most common. At least this year all
have thrived, the lake trout have been common in the over 3# size, likewise the Bass and even Crappie have been running in the 2-3# range. We have had quite a
few Bass taken over 9 pounds this year, trout over 7 pounds and Catfish over 10 pounds as well. While I haven't been in the running for those really big
ones this summer, Ive been lucky enough to have caught and released an abundence of Bass and Trout, keeping only a few for weekend dinners, the Crappie
likewise has fed quite a few visiting friends and family. Anyway this summer my almost daily rod was a Phillipson Johnson Profile 800 7 1/2 ft 6wt using an
Orvis Wonderline WF6F bonefish (actually a 6.5wt bass taper), fishing poppers, medium large dry flys and a few smaller wet flys that I only allow to sink
enough to take the tippet and leader under, those little bead head wet flys, usually Im getting hit in 7-10ft with slightly weighted bead head wet flys. Anyway
Im usually in by the time the winds kick up too much so the little 6wt works out nicely. The Fiberglass Phillipson is one of the most comfortable to fish Ive
ever own. On days when I just plain want to fish a short while against a wind I take a vintage glass Conolon 9ft 9-10wt Bass rod fully equipted with a FW10F
Bass taper line and fight the winds until my arm gets tired flailing around with over a pound of rod, reel and line in the wind. Still the monster rods do
serve their purpose, on days I wouldn't be able to fly fish I am and can, and catch fish too.
Last part of the question about being boat bound, I would take along a Bass weight Spinning Rod to be able to fish some of those lures and artifical soft plastic frogs and such when nothing else will work on picky Bass. Sometimes when your invited along with someone in their Bass Boat your given little choice as too the best locations to fish with a fly rod. If I really wanted to be on the ball I would take my Phillipson Swamp Fox, its one of those 4 piece spin/fly rods, 6wt fly rod and with spinning reel still able to handle medium soft plastics and light lures. Richard |
||||
|
|
||||
Wee Hooker |
#11 | |||
|
I had bad experiences with glass in my early days of flyfishing. If it wern't for graphite composites, and then latter all graphite rods, I ahve no doubt i
would have given up flyfishing a long time ago. I don't have much experience with bamboo, but generally found that rods in the 6wt and higher range, got
tireing for me to cast. My prefference is for IM6 graphite and moderate to moderte-fast tapers. These seem to give the best ballance of lightnesss,
durability, power and general "sweet feel" to me. If I could take only 1 rod ( and i'd argur HARD for two) it would be a 8.5-9', 6 or 7 wt
in a Mod-fast Im6 blank.
|
||||
|
|
||||
anglerdave |
#12 | |||
|
I only own one glass and two boo rods, but for the species that you mention, I would bring a St Croix Avid 9' 6wt. This is their newer version and I
really like this rod. I would carry one spool with a standard weight forward line and add a mini sink tip on the other.
"I still don't know why I fish or why other men fish, except that we like it and it makes us think and feel." Roderick Haig - Brown. |
||||
|
|
||||
bulldog1935 |
#13 | |||
|
I find graphite not too useful for warmwater, but that's probably because of the water I normally fish.
Go-to is also a relative term, because I match the rod to the water size, flow, overhang and fish. But my first choices will be cane and glass. I prefer cane in 8' and 8-1/2' rods, and prefer glass 7-1/2' and shorter. |
||||
|
|
||||
armyflyfisher |
#14 | |||
|
It depends!....on conditions....anticipated fish size....size of the water......etc etc etc.
My "go to's" lately for stream and small ponds have been my Fenwick FF755 (see my avatar) fiberglass with a DT5....or my FF806 'glass with a DT7 or my 7'6" 6wt ST Croix graphite "Premier" with a Cortland 555 150 gr. sinking line to get deep....or my Echo graphite "Classic" 3wt with a DT4 which is a HOOT with small pan fish. David |
||||
|
|
||||